Trying to land the MLB All-Star Game? Here’s what matters (and doesn’t).

2 years ago 168

ARLINGTON, Tex. — As Major League Baseball completed its all-star events in the Dallas-Fort Worth area this week, eyes started to turn to Georgia’s Cobb County, where the Atlanta Braves and Truist Park will host the game in 2025.

Atlanta was in line to host in 2021 but lost the event amid backlash to changes in Georgia’s voting law, and MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred shifted it to Denver. The decision, which was part of a wave of corporate pushback, was not unprecedented. The NBA, for example, pulled the 2017 All-Star Game from Charlotte because of concerns with North Carolina’s transgender bathroom law.

But in baseball, it represented a stark departure — both for the event and the sport as a whole. MLB generally doesn’t weigh in on social issues. Nor do those social issues generally impact the locations of its major events. The process for awarding an All-Star Game, according to those who have been involved, is focused on the practical — hotels, traffic, logistics — not the political. Those reasons, for example, are why the baseball world gathered at Globe Life Field for this week’s All-Star Game.

Globe Life Field is the home of the Texas Rangers, a franchise that sometimes draws attention not just for what it offers fans on the field but also for what it does not at the ballpark: a Pride Night. Pride Nights, focused on inclusion and members of the LGBTQ community, are commonplace in sports, including in MLB. The Rangers are the only MLB team that does not host one.

“There are a whole lot of factors that go into deciding who’s going to get an All-Star Game. I don’t view whether you hold a Pride Night or not as an outcome-determinant issue,” Manfred said. “It’s an issue. We look at all those issues and try to make a decision and give it to the place that we think is going to be the best.”

Manfred’s comments did not come as a surprise to Rafael McDonnell, senior advocacy and policy manager at Resource Center, an LGBTQIA group in the Dallas area, who said he was nevertheless disappointed to hear them.

“I have asked people at MLB to ask him to use his bully pulpit on behalf of the North Texas LGBTQ community, and they have said no,” McDonnell said. “So this does not surprise me one bit.”

MLB did not ask the Rangers to host a Pride Night when it awarded the event to Texas, according to a person with direct knowledge of the process, despite years of urging from local LGBTQ advocates.

Outside of the 2021 Atlanta decision, MLB has little history of using its major events to push on social issues. Teams pull together bids with details of what their cities offer, including hotel availability and sentimental considerations. Franchises negotiate with local leaders to secure necessary funding for added transportation and security costs, all of which go into the bid.

In some ways, the perceived leverage MLB has with the game might be greater than the actual. Multiple executives with teams that have hosted All-Star Games in the past five years emphasized that the event did not make their franchises money and said cities, not clubs, see most of the benefits. Small-market teams generally expect the game to generate around $60 million in revenue for their city. In larger markets, officials plan for as much as $100 million.

Those municipalities, however, usually invest millions in security and logistics. Even ticket sales are split evenly among all 30 teams, so the host receives only a percentage of game-day revenue. Hosting is an honor for any franchise, but it is not necessarily a direct financial boon.

The event is also coveted for the branding impact it can have. Washington Nationals managing principal owner Mark Lerner joked that his family started asking to host a game minutes after they took over the club. Chicago Cubs leadership has also been trying to host a game for years, their eagerness best illustrated by the fact that they have endured negotiations over how to handle road closures with three mayors. To this point, none of those years-long negotiations has yielded an agreement between the state, city and team over who will pay the costs of redirecting traffic around Addison and Clark. So they wait.

Security or transportation logistics can determine when MLB turns to one city over another. Historical context occasionally matters, too: The Philadelphia Phillies, for example, wanted a game to mark the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. They will host in 2026.

Manfred said Tuesday that the last time a city hosted is also a consideration. A long wait can have a positive impact. So the Baltimore Orioles, who have not hosted since 1993, should be able to secure the event in the near future with a strong bid, even as they transition to new owner David Rubenstein, who plans to renovate Camden Yards.

“Baltimore has expressed interest in an All-Star Game. With the transition, exactly where that application sits, we’re kind of in a little bit of flux,” Manfred said. “And I don’t see the completion of the renovation as necessarily dictating the timing of when the game takes place.”

Giving the game back to Atlanta next year was devoid of the political prerequisites the decision to move it four years earlier might have implied.

Officially, the Braves had the best bid for 2025. Logistically, they had a new ballpark and an event hub. Realistically, MLB owed them one. Georgia’s controversial voting law remained in effect, but the Braves got their game back anyway.

“As a model of success on and off the field, the Braves deserve to host the All-Star Game,” Manfred said in a statement then. “Truist Park and The Battery Atlanta will provide fans a world-class experience in 2025.”

As for the Rangers, they have a new stadium. They have space. Plus the Rangers helped MLB in 2020 by hosting games in the neutral-site postseason during the coronavirus pandemic.

“And it’s really important here,” Manfred said, “to remember there’s a massive public investment in terms of creating a great new facility. And honestly, that’s an important consideration in terms of awarding All-Star Games.”

MLB pointed to diversity and inclusion events held around the area amid the all-star festivities this past week. The Rangers, when asked about majority owner Ray Davis’s reluctance to hold a Pride Night, annually point out the work the organization has done with McDonnell’s advocacy group and cite a commitment to making fans of all kinds welcome.

McDonnell lauded the Rangers for their support of the Gay Softball World Series when it came to the area and has found the organization a receptive partner in creating a more inclusive work environment.

“This is a weird hill to stake out for them. They’ve engaged with us on a number of things. If you were to think they aren’t doing anything and are having no involvement, that’s absolutely not correct,” said McDonnell, a Rangers fan who attended some of this week’s events. “It’s just that this is where they’re hanging their hat, which is weird.”

He also emphasized that he appreciates the work MLB has done to promote diversity and inclusion elsewhere, noting the “29 success stories” it has outside Dallas. McDonnell also said he believes it will have a 30th soon.

“To be a baseball fan,” he said, “you have to be an optimist.”

Read Entire Article