The biggest winners and losers in fantasy football from the NFL draft

2 years ago 159

The NFL draft has come and gone, and all that’s left is to wait 18 weeks or so for the season to actually begin. In the meantime, there are plenty of fantasy drafts to enter (mostly best-ball, of course, before leagues get going), and with that in mind, here are some winners and losers from the three-day extravaganza we just enjoyed.

Note that this analysis has a redraft frame, as opposed to dynasty, so we’ll be mostly interested here in the 2024 outlooks for these players.

Winners

Caleb Williams, QB, Bears

Normally, teams that get the No. 1 pick are, shall we say, terrible. So when they draft a quarterback first overall, he usually gets tossed into a poor situation, as was the case with Bryce Young last year. That will not be the case with Williams, whose not-terrible new team benefited from a tremendous trade with Young’s team and has given the former Southern California star all sorts of weapons.

Even before drafting talented wide receiver Rome Odunze ninth overall, Chicago had two high-end wide receivers on hand in D.J. Moore and Keenan Allen, plus a pair of passing game-friendly tight ends in Cole Kmet and Gerald Everett. For their part, the Bears’ running backs, notably D’Andre Swift and Roschon Johnson, are capable of catching passes and breaking big plays. Add Williams’s rushing ability, and he looks like a top-12 fantasy QB.

Kyler Murray, QB, Cardinals and Marvin Harrison Jr., WR, Cardinals

The 6-foot-3, 209-pound Harrison figures to quickly establish himself as Arizona’s top wide receiver, a status that would assure him of a torrent of targets from Murray, who reestablished himself last year as one of the NFL’s better quarterbacks. Coming off a torn ACL, Murray didn’t take the field until Week 10 and failed to notch a 300-yard passing day, but he was a steady performer before catching fire down the stretch. Over the Cardinals’ final three games, Murray completed 71.7 percent of his passes for 724 yards, six touchdowns, one interception and a 108.3 rating. He also averaged 30 yards rushing over that stretch, a number that could increase this year as he puts his knee injury further in the rearview mirror.

While Murray helped tight end Trey McBride come into his own as a target magnet, that was in part because the quarterback wasn’t exactly working with a stacked deck of wide receivers. With Harrison promising to play the leading-man role more than the departed Marquise Brown, the likes of Michael Wilson and Greg Dortch can slot into more appropriate, supporting-cast roles. It would not be crazy to take Harrison in the second round of drafts and to have Murray in the QB10 range.

Zamir White, RB, Raiders

Las Vegas waited until the sixth round to draft a running back, Dylan Laube, who played at Football Championship Subdivision program New Hampshire and profiles at least initially as a receiving back. In other words, Laube is more of a threat to Ameer Abdullah’s role than that of White, who should get most of the early-down and goal-line work. White isn’t completely out of the woods, given the presence of Alexander Mattison and the possibility of a post-draft free agency addition, but he has a great shot at giving managers RB2 production at a very affordable price.

Nice vote of confidence from #Raiders in Zamir White this offseason:

1. Let Josh Jacobs walk in free agency

2. Only added Alexander Mattison, PFF's No. 56 RB among 63 qualifiers last season

3. Used just 1-of-8 draft picks at RB, a Round 6 pick on pass-catcher Dylan Laube

— Adam Levitan (@adamlevitan) April 28, 2024

Ladd McConkey, WR, Chargers

During the primary free agency period, Los Angeles waved goodbye to Mike Williams, traded away Allen to the Bears and didn’t sign anyone to replace them. Of course, that fit with new coach Jim Harbaugh’s expected plans to install a run-heavy scheme — as did the Chargers’ first-round selection of offensive tackle Joe Alt — but someone has to catch a pass or two at some point. Enter McConkey, who was plucked early in the second round after earning praise at Georgia for his route running and at the draft combine for his impressive athletic measurements. All McConkey has to do to become the apple of Justin Herbert’s eye is prove a superior option to the uninspiring likes of Quentin Johnston, a 2023 first-round pick who looked bust-y as a rookie, Josh Palmer and Derius Davis.

Incumbent Falcons pass-catchers

Look, analysts can be apoplectic at Atlanta for drafting Michael Penix Jr. when it already had a recently signed Kirk Cousins, but that’s hardly a problem for Drake London, Kyle Pitts, Bijan Robinson and Darnell Mooney. If the Falcons, universally expected to take a defensive player or trade out of the eighth pick, wanted to go merely rogue there rather than completely unhinged, they could have taken Odunze. Instead, Atlanta didn’t draft a pass-catcher until the sixth round, and the combination of Cousins and Penix should ensure a minimum of competent quarterbacking even if one gets injured.

Losers

Brock Bowers, TE, Raiders

Generally predicted to go somewhere in the top 12, where he could have landed as the No. 1 or No. 2 pass-catcher for several teams (i.e., the Chargers, Giants, Jets or Broncos), Bowers ended up in a muddled situation on a team that could want to move in a more ground-oriented approach under Coach Antonio Pierce. Not only will Bowers have to contend for targets with Davante Adams and Jakobi Meyers, but also with Michael Mayer, a well-regarded tight end the Raiders drafted in the second round just last year.

Of course, the team can and likely will run a lot of two-TE sets, but another issue for Bowers is the quality of quarterbacking he’ll get from Gardner Minshew and Aidan O’Connell. In the right situation, Bowers might have pushed for top-five consideration at his position, but now top-12 could be best for which we can hope.

Kyren Williams, RB, Rams

Undersized and not particularly athletic (compared to other running backs, that is, a certain middle-aged sportswriter was quick to add), Williams was able to burst into fantasy prominence by dominating the Rams’ backfield workload. There’s no reason to feel he has lost the trust of Sean McVay, but the coach/offensive guru has proven fickle at times in the past and just signed off on the drafting of Blake Corum in the third round. Even more ominous is that the 5-8, 205-pound Corum, whose combine performance stood out for his strength rather than his speed, resembles Williams in many ways. It’s harder to like Williams as a first-round fantasy pick when he’s facing the prospect of fending off his doppelgänger.

Breece Hall, RB, Jets

I’d still take Hall in the first round, but much closer to the bottom, behind all the top pass-catchers, than the middle. With several moves in the draft, New York signaled it may take valuable touches off his plate, including some of his position-leading 76 receptions from last season. The Jets’ third-round pick, Malachi “YAC King” Corley, is technically a wide receiver but has something of a running back build (5-11, 215 pounds) and did most of his considerable college damage with passes at or near the line of scrimmage. Hall could also lose a fair amount of goal-line work, given that his team drafted not one but two actual running backs (Braelon Allen and Isaiah Davis), both of whom profile as bruisers adept in short-yardage situations.

Jonathon Brooks, RB, Panthers

Widely thought to be a target for the running back-needy Cowboys — even before loose-lipped owner Jerry Jones let slip that Brooks was “high, high, high” on their list — the Texas product was poached by the Panthers before Dallas could wait for him to land in its lap in the second round. So instead of vying with Rico Dowdle and possibly Ezekiel Elliott for top-dog status in an excellent Cowboys offense, Brooks has to contend with the well-graded Chuba Hubbard and maybe Miles Sanders in whatever attack Carolina can muster. Given that Brooks is coming off an ACL tear and that the Panthers should not have ambitions for great success this year, they may even make the sensible choice to bring him along slowly.

Ricky Pearsall, WR, 49ers

It should be very good news for Pearsall that he landed in the first round after several analysts foresaw him going in the second. It definitely is good news for him that he’ll have the benefit of Kyle Shanahan’s bright offensive mind and Brock Purdy’s precision passing in San Francisco. It’s just that, despite all sorts of speculation, the 49ers did not trade either Deebo Samuel or Brandon Aiyuk in the draft, meaning that Pearsall has two top-notch wide receivers above him in the pecking order. Even if one does get traded between now and September, the 49ers also have to budget targets for George Kittle, Christian McCaffrey and, to a lesser degree, Jauan Jennings, leaving only a small slice of the 2024 pie for Pearsall.

Read Entire Article