States where abortion is on the ballot in the 2024 election

2 years ago 173

Voters in about a dozen states could decide the fate of abortion rights in November with constitutional amendments on the ballot in a pivotal election year — including in several battleground states that will be key to deciding the presidential race and which party controls Congress.

Abortion rights advocates have reason to be hopeful: Since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade in June 2022, every ballot measure that has sought to preserve or expand abortion access has been successful, while those that have sought to restrict abortion access have failed — even in states that skew conservative.

The push to protect reproductive rights has been buoyed by the imposition of recent restrictions at the state level. In Florida, a ruling by the state’s Supreme Court cleared the way for a six-week abortion ban to go into effect on May 1. Similarly, Arizona’s Supreme Court ruled in April that a near-total ban dating back to 1864 — before Arizona had become a state — could go into effect.

President Biden and Democrats have seized on reproductive rights as a key issue on which to attack Republicans and former president Donald Trump, the presumptive GOP nominee, who has repeatedly taken credit for appointing three of the Supreme Court justices who later helped overturn Roe. Trump has also said that abortion policy should be left to the states.

Return to menu

Current law: Florida’s Supreme Court ruled in April that the state’s constitution does not protect abortion rights. The case centered on the state’s existing 15-week ban, which took effect in the summer of 2022. But the court’s ruling triggered a far stricter law passed last year and signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) that will outlaw abortion after six weeks of pregnancy, before many people know they’re pregnant. Florida’s six-week ban is slated to take effect May 1.

The initiative: The citizen-driven initiative to pass the Amendment to Limit Government Interference with Abortion is led by Floridians Protecting Freedom. It would codify in the state constitution a right to abortion until “viability.”

State of play: The group says it surpassed the required 891,523 verified signatures due by Feb. 1. Florida’s Supreme Court, in a separate decision in April, ruled that the amendment can go on the November ballot, a vote that could undo the six-week abortion ban in a matter of months.

The politics: Florida is a crucial state for the abortion rights movement. Former president Donald Trump now calls Florida home and won the state by more than three percentage points in 2020. There is also a Senate race in Florida that is seen as a pickup opportunity for Democrats.

Return to menu

Current law: Since 1992, Maryland has allowed abortion until viability and after viability if the life or health of the mother is at risk, or if the fetus isn’t viable.

The initiative: The Right to Reproductive Freedom initiative is a legislative-backed measure that would add the right to an abortion to the Declaration of Rights section in the state constitution.

State of play: The measure failed in the legislature before Roe was overturned, but a revived bill passed both chambers with the required 60 percent support in 2023, placing it on the November ballot.

The politics: Maryland is a deep-blue state that Biden won by more than 33 percentage points. Abortion rights advocates hope candidates vowing to protect rights will be buoyed by the ballot measure in local races.

Return to menu

Current law: Abortion until 24 weeks gestation is legal in New York.

The initiative: A legislature-driven initiative would protect abortion rights as part of an expanded Equal Rights Amendment that will appear on the ballot in November. The measure would protect against discrimination for pregnancy and pregnancy outcomes and would protect against government action that could limit reproductive care.

State of play: The New York legislature fulfilled the requirement of passing the ERA twice consecutively through the legislature — in July 2022 and again in January 2023. It will be on the ballot in November.

The politics: New York is a blue state that Biden won by more than 30 points. But New York will be a crucial battleground to determine control of the U.S. House with seven competitive seats.

Return to menu

Current law: In April, Arizona’s Supreme Court upheld a territorial law — one that was passed in 1864, before Arizona became a state — that bans and criminalizes almost all abortions. Though state Attorney General Kris Mayes (D) has vowed not to enforce the law, the ban is expected to threaten abortion providers.

The initiative: Arizona for Abortion Access, a coalition of abortion rights advocates, is behind a proposed ballot measure that would enshrine the right to an abortion in the state’s constitution.

State of play: The campaign must submit 383,923 valid signatures by July 3 to appear on the 2024 ballot. Advocates have already gathered more than enough signatures to qualify, according to the Arizona Republic. A simple majority is required to pass the ballot measure.

The politics: Arizona is a battleground state that will be critical this year. Rep. Ruben Gallego (D) and Republican Kari Lake are in a tight race for the Senate seat held by Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (I-Ariz.), who is not seeking reelection. In 2020, Biden won Arizona by only 0.3 percentage points, becoming the first Democratic presidential candidate to win there since 1996.

Return to menu

Current law: Nevada state law allows abortion up to 24 weeks of pregnancy and after 24 weeks when a doctor has “reasonable cause” to believe it is “necessary to preserve the life or health of the pregnant person.”

The initiatives: A coalition called Nevadans for Reproductive Freedom filed paperwork last year for a ballot initiative that would amend the state constitution to make “decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy” a fundamental right.

The group filed a second, narrower petition that would enshrine into the Nevada constitution the right to an abortion “until fetal viability, or when needed to protect the life or health of the pregnant patient.”

State of play: A district court judge struck down the group’s first petition, saying it covered more than a single subject, but abortion rights advocates are hopeful the state’s Supreme Court will rule in their favor on appeal. The campaign must submit 102,362 valid signatures for either petition by June 26.

Nevada requires two consecutive votes of the people to amend the constitution through a citizen-initiated ballot measure — meaning that, if the ballot measure passes with a simple majority in 2024, the question will return to the ballot in 2026.

The politics: Biden narrowly carried Nevada in 2020, and the battleground state continues to produce extremely tight races: In 2022, Democratic Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto won reelection by 0.8 percentage points. Having an abortion measure on the ballot in November could help Biden as well as Sen. Jacky Rosen (D), who is facing a tough race for reelection.

Return to menu

Current law: Montana has abortion protections in the state constitution under the right to privacy, though Republicans — who control the governor’s office and both chambers of the legislature — tried to pursue restrictions.

The initiative: An group called Montanans Securing Reproductive Rights filed paperwork in November for a ballot measure that would affirm in the state constitution the “right to make and carry out decisions about one’s own pregnancy, including the right to abortion.”

State of play: In April, the Montana Supreme Court approved revised language for the measure. Advocates have received the green light to begin signature gathering and must submit 60,359 valid signatures by July 19.

Montana voters in 2022 rejected a referendum that would have criminalized medical professionals if they did not give care to any infant born alive at any stage of development. The so-called born alive referendum was criticized for mischaracterizing abortions, and it was ultimately defeated at the polls by more than five percentage points.

The politics: Sen. Jon Tester (D) is seeking reelection to a fourth term, to the relief of many Democrats as the party faces a tough Senate map in 2024. Having an abortion measure on the ballot could boost Democratic turnout and help Tester.

Return to menu

Current law: Missouri has a near-total ban on abortion, with exceptions only for life endangerment and medical emergencies, that went into effect after Roe was overturned.

The initiative: A group called Missourians for Constitutional Freedom is seeking to overturn the ban by enshrining in the state’s constitution “the right to make and carry out decisions about all matters relating to reproductive health care,” including abortion care.

State of play: After a long legal fight over ballot measure language, advocates began gathering signatures in January. The group must submit at least 171,592 valid signatures by May 5 to appear on the ballot. Republican lawmakers in the state legislature, however, are pushing bills that would make it harder to amend the state constitution through ballot initiatives.

The politics: Missouri has some of the strictest restrictions on abortion in the country, and the state — which Trump won by more than 15 points in 2020 — is reliably conservative. Sen. Josh Hawley (R) is up for reelection this year against a to-be-determined Democratic opponent.

Return to menu

Current law: Arkansas has a near-total ban on abortion, with exceptions only for life endangerment, that went into effect after Roe was overturned.

The initiative: A group called Arkansans for Limited Government proposed a constitutional amendment that prohibits the state from restricting abortion services within 18 weeks of fertilization, as well as in cases of rape, incest, fetal anomaly or to protect a pregnant person’s life or physical well-being.

State of play: After twice rejecting language for the ballot measure, the Arkansas attorney general certified the proposal in January. Advocates must collect 90,704 valid signatures by July 5 to gain ballot access.

The politics: Ruby-red Arkansas will be an extremely challenging state for advocates to succeed in passing a measure expanding abortion access. Republicans control the governor’s office and both chambers of the legislature, and the entire congressional delegation is Republican. The group behind the measure is arguing that matters such as abortion “are private and not to be dictated by the government.”

Return to menu

Current law: A trigger law banning all abortions in South Dakota, with no exceptions for rape or incest, went into effect after the Supreme Court overturned Roe. In addition, state law dictates that anyone who helps someone procure an abortion, unless deemed medically necessary to preserve the life of a pregnant person, could face a felony charge.

The initiative: Dakotans for Health last year filed paperwork proposing a citizen-initiated ballot measure that would establish a right to an abortion in the state’s constitution. If passed, the state could not regulate abortion during the first trimester of pregnancy, could regulate abortion if “reasonably related to the physical health of the pregnant woman” during the second trimester, and could regulate or even ban abortion in the third trimester, with exceptions for “life or health of the pregnant woman.”

State of play: National reproductive rights groups are sitting out this campaign, saying the language in the proposed ballot measure will not do enough to restore abortion rights. Advocates must submit 35,017 signatures by May 7 to get on the ballot — where it needs a simple majority to pass.

The politics: Trump defeated Biden in the state in 2020 with nearly 62 percent of the vote, and Republicans control the governor’s office and both chambers of the state legislature. All three members of the congressional delegation are Republican.

Possible ballot measures to protect and restrict abortion rights

Return to menu

Return to menu

Current law: Colorado is the first state to statutorily protect abortion. It did so in 1967, five years before Roe was originally decided. While Colorado has had few limits on abortion, a proposition passed in 1984 restricted the use of health insurance and Medicaid for abortion.

The initiatives: One ballot initiative would enshrine the right to abortion in the state constitution and would allow health insurance coverage of an abortion.

Another ballot initiative would ban abortions without exception. It would also penalize facilities that provide abortions as well as individuals and providers who provide tools or medications used to perform abortions.

State of play: The initiative to enshrine abortion rights is being supported by a coalition called Coloradans for Protecting Reproductive Freedom. The antiabortion ballot measure was filed by representatives of the Colorado Life Initiative.

For each initiative, 124,238 valid signatures are required. The measures would then be a yes-or-no vote on the ballot, requiring 55 percent “yes” votes to be adopted.

Coloradans for Protecting Reproductive Freedom announced Friday that it has collected 225,000 signatures statewide. The group said it still must collect sufficient signatures in three state Senate districts to satisfy the state’s ballot initiative distribution requirement.

Abortion rights advocates beat back a ballot initiative in 2020 to restrict abortion rights before Roe was overturned. Coloradans overwhelmingly defeated it, outperforming Biden at the top of the ticket by 25,000 votes and Democrat John Hickenlooper, who won the Senate race, by more than 100,000 votes.

The politics: Abortion rights groups have long been on the defensive. This is the first time they are being proactive and trying to pass a measure that enshrines the right in the constitution. Advocates were intentional in choosing a presidential year when voter turnout is expected to be high. Colorado has at least two competitive House races, including that of Rep. Lauren Boebert (R).

Return to menu

Current law: After Roe fell, the Nebraska legislature passed a 12-week abortion ban with no exceptions for the life and health of the mother after falling one vote short of a six-week ban.

The initiatives: One citizen-driven group, Protect Our Rights, is proposing a constitutional amendment to protect a right to abortion until “fetal viability.”

Another ballot initiative, brought by a group of Nebraska medical professionals and backed by antiabortion groups, would ban abortions after the first trimester, with exceptions for rape, incest and medical emergencies. The Nebraska Family Alliance, one of the effort’s proponents, argues that by giving constitutional protections to “preborn children” in the state, the ballot initiative would establish “a floor of protection … and stronger pro-life laws could still be passed going forward.”

State of play: Advocates for both initiatives have begun collecting the roughly 128,000 signatures of registered voters who hail from 38 counties as required by July.

The politics: Nebraska is a deep-red state, voting for Trump by 29 percentage points in 2020. Voters are increasingly using ballot initiatives in Nebraska to advance objectives the legislature refuses to take up. While incumbent Sen. Deb Fischer (R) is expected to easily win reelection, if the abortion initiative makes the ballot, it could impact the race of Rep. Don Bacon (R), who is one of the 17 Republican House members who represent a district Biden won in 2020.

Return to menu

Current law: The state legislature passed a six-week abortion ban in July that is being tested in the courts. Days after Roe was overturned, courts in Iowa reversed a previous decision that protected the right to an abortion.

The initiative: Antiabortion groups are pushing a legislative initiative that would prohibit the right to an abortion in the Iowa constitution. The “no right to an abortion amendment” says the “Constitution does not recognize, grant, or secure a right to abortion or require the public funding of abortion.”

State of play: Both chambers of the General Assembly must pass the amendment in two consecutive sessions. Lawmakers passed the measure in the last session and must pass it for a second time in the current session that ends Tuesday for it to be on the ballot in November. Given the time constraints and complicated legislative approvals needed, Iowa voters will likely not decide this question this year.

The politics: Iowa has become a reliably Republican state in recent elections, with Biden losing by eight points in 2020. The state has at least one House race that could be competitive. Abortion rights groups are skeptical that the General Assembly will advance the amendment again after antiabortion defeats in similarly red Kansas and Ohio, fearing it could boost Democratic turnout in a presidential election year.

Return to menu

Current law: Abortion in Pennsylvania is legal through the 23rd week of pregnancy. After that, abortions are permitted in certain cases when the health of a pregnant person is in danger.

The initiative: In 2022, state lawmakers approved a constitutional amendment that declared that the commonwealth’s charter provides no right to an abortion. If that were passed for a second time in the legislature, it would go to a statewide referendum.

State of play: It’s unlikely Pennsylvania lawmakers will approve the amendment again this year because Democrats have taken control of the state House.

The politics: While Trump took Pennsylvania in 2016, Biden won the commonwealth with 50 percent of the vote in 2020 and Democrats picked up a Senate seat two years later. This election cycle, Sen. Bob Casey (D) faces a competitive reelection race.

Danielle Paquette, Molly Hennessy-Fiske and Annie Gowen contributed to this report.

Read Entire Article