HSBC Bank balance can’t be taxed, says I-T tribunal

2 years ago 167

Synopsis

In a decision that could have a bearing on other `HSBC account’ cases, a tax tribunal last week has ruled that the I-T department cannot go back 16 years to reopen old matters to tax the ‘peak balance’ lying in such bank accounts. Why? Because, according to the Mumbai bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal --- a quasi judicial authority --- a bank balance reflects 'assets' and not ‘income’, and, under the law, only income can be taxed.

HSBC Bank balance Can’t be taxed, says I-T tribunalReutersTill now, in many HSBC matters, tax claims have been raised on the maximum amounts that were lying in the bank accounts.

Almost 14 years after the sensational data leak from HSBC Geneva, a tax order has questioned the very approach of the Income Tax (I-T) department in going after individuals whose names figured in the infamous list of information that was stolen by an employee of the Swiss private banking arm of the British bank.

In a decision that could have a bearing on other `HSBC account’ cases, a tax tribunal last week has ruled that the I-T department cannot go back 16 years to reopen old matters to tax the ‘peak balance’ lying in such bank accounts. Why? Because, according to the Mumbai bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal --- a quasi judicial authority --- a bank balance reflects 'assets' and not ‘income’, and, under the law, only income can be taxed.

Till now, in many HSBC matters, tax claims have been raised on the maximum amounts that were lying in the bank accounts --- primarily because that was the only information that the I-T department had in 2010-11 when it received the data.

Under the old law, which was invoked in this matter, the I-T department could go back up to 6 years to tax undisclosed local income (exceeding Rs 1 lakh) and up to 16 years to go after overseas income that had escaped tax. HSBC cases were reopened under both the provisions (6 years and 16 years) and both these provisions (under the old law) allowed taxation of income (and not assets).

Under the present law, the department can reopen an assessment up to 10 years if it suspects that the untaxed income is more than Rs 50 lakh. The 16-year provision (applicable earlier only in terms of offshore incomes) no longer exists in the law and the taxman today primarily relies on the Black Money Act, which was passed in 2015, to nab unreported overseas wealth and income. However, once a matter is taken up under the old law, the department may find it difficult to invoke the Black Money Act.

The present case (falling between 6 and 16 years) pertains to assessment year 2006-07, with the I-T department having issued the notice in March 2014.

QUESTION OVER ‘BASE NOTE’
Interestingly, the tribunal in its ruling has also recorded the argument questioning the authenticity of the key document which the tax office relied upon. In the matter, pertaining to the assessment year 2006-07, the I-T department had attached a ‘base note’ along with the notice that was served on the assessee. In the course of the hearing, the latter’s counsel had pointed out that the amounts mentioned in the base note is stated in ‘lakhs’, and not in `thousands’ as is found in the statements of banks overseas. Also, the note does not bear the name of the stamp, bank name, letterhead; and, gives no reason as to why the amount in an offshore bank should be taxed in India.

While these observations on the ‘base note’ may have a peripheral relevance to ongoing HSBC cases, assessees named in the latter may in future draw on the Tribunal’s recent interpretation of Section 149 that allowed reopening within 16 years of the assessment. Referring to the section, the Tribunal ruling said: “…the income from (the) bank account in Geneva has neither accrued nor arisen or deemed to have accrued or arisen in India. Further, no part of income from (the) alleged bank accounts has been received or deemed to be received in India.”

“The evidentiary value of ‘base note’ has been in question ever since 2011, when searches / reassessment cases have been initiated solely on such ‘base note’. This is a positive ruling recording arguments around the admissibility of ‘base note’ and ultimately holding that the reassessment proceedings could not have been initiated in the hands of a non-resident of India. It has been held that the tax department was not able to prove that any ‘income’ from the Bank account in HSBC, Geneva has been received in India or accrued / arise or deemed to have accrued / arisen in India. Merely adding the peak balance (which is an ‘asset’ and not ‘income’) does not provide jurisdiction to the tax authorities to invoke the reassessment proceedings,” said Ashish Mehta, Partner at the law firm Khaitan & Co. Mumbai.

According to tax practitioners, in several cases foreign accounts were structured in a way where an offshore trust (in which individuals were beneficiaries) held shares of companies (possibly in tax havens) which had accounts in HSBC, Switzerland. There is, however, no evidence that such a structure was used by the assessee who had categorically denied having any bank account with HSBC Geneva. Indeed, the `base note' (produced by the taxman) did not have the assessee’s name but mentioned two companies without linking them with the assessee.Ok...

For the I-T to treat unreported or unexplained credits as taxable income (as it often does), it should be apparent that the bank account belongs to the assessee. This can be even tougher for the department if the assessee (as is the case here) was also an NRI in the particular year.

HIGHLIGHTS

  • India received the HSBC data in 2010-11
  • Most named denied links with the bank a/cs
  • Notices were served, prosecution initiated in some
  • Some signed ‘consent waiver’, accepting the charges
Read Entire Article