Condemnation before cause: The House GOP lashes out once again

2 years ago 116

There is a serious question to be asked about the extent to which House Republicans understand that the effort to impeach President Biden failed. Not just as a political exercise, but as an effort to dig up inculpatory evidence revealing that Joe Biden was involved with his son’s and brother’s business efforts to a significant degree.

After all, these Republicans are generally, if not necessarily, embedded in a right-wing media universe in which the failings of that probe are glossed over or ignored and in which untrue, debunked or discredited information is hailed as evidence of serious criminality.

On Wednesday, Rep. Tom Tiffany (R-Wis.) stepped outside the right’s comfortable bubble for an interview on CNN. Host Boris Sanchez asked Tiffany about the Republican-led effort to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in contempt of Congress before pivoting to a social media post from Tiffany celebrating Hunter Biden’s conviction.

“This is just the beginning of holding the Biden Crime Family accountable,” Tiffany wrote about the verdict handed down against the president’s son. “Now let’s do Joe Biden.”

Tiffany offered a familiar litany of alleged evidence that Joe Biden was somehow involved in Hunter Biden’s business and repeated a familiar claim about money from foreign places flowing to people named Biden. Sanchez pushed back with a fact check, noting that Tiffany was overstating dollar amounts and that no money was shown to have gone to Biden from foreign parties.

“Well, Joe Biden has a check in the amount of $40,000 that has his name on it,” Tiffany rebutted. “You got another $200,000 check that came from Jim and Sarah Biden to him. I mean, there’s over $20 million —”

Sanchez jumped in to note that these were payments from Joe Biden’s brother to him, that they were repayments of loans and that they happened when Biden wasn’t in office.

So Tiffany tried again: Well, what about when Biden was vice president and called for the ouster of Ukraine’s top prosecutor? As Sanchez noted, this, too, has been repeatedly explained. The prosecutor wasn’t targeting the company for which Hunter Biden worked and was targeted himself for being corrupt — and not only by Joe Biden. Etc., etc. If you’ve been paying attention to non-Fox News for the past five years, you’ve heard this before.

If you’re paying attention to Fox News, though, you hear something different.

“Justice has not been served,” House Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer (R-Ky.) said on Jesse Watters’s prime-time show Tuesday. “Justice will not be served until the Department of Justice takes into account all of the financial crimes that the entire Biden family committed. It wasn’t just Hunter Biden. It was also Joe Biden and Jim Biden.”

Comer — along with House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) and (to a lesser extent) House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Jason T. Smith (R-Mo.) — is one of the people centrally responsible for prosecuting the case against Biden. It is Comer who keeps exaggerating how significant the accrued evidence is and it is Comer to whom right-wing media outlets and his peers look for information. If you are a member of the House Republican conference and are relying on Comer to update you on the evidence that has been found, you’re at dire risk of believing that you’ve got a lot more than you do.

Jordan, for one, seems to recognize that the “Joe Biden was on the take” argument doesn’t have legs. After special counsel Robert K. Hur released his report recommending against charging Biden for possessing classified documents — and sharply criticizing the president’s mental acuity — Jordan began pivoting to Hur as a more viable line of political attack.

On Sean Hannity’s Fox News show in March, Jordan was asked about the impeachment probe.

“What we really want now,” Jordan replied, “is we want the information Robert K. Hur has.”

The Justice Department released a transcript of the interview Hur conducted with Biden. But House Republicans, led by Jordan, wanted the audio recording, purportedly out of concern that the transcript might misrepresent what Biden actually said. The request submitted by subpoena was win-win; get the audio and you can cherry-pick verbal fumbles for campaign spots or get rejected and cast the administration as obstructive.

This was the play last year, when Comer and Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) demanded that the FBI release notes about an interview in which Biden was accused of bribery. The FBI indicated that it didn’t want the document released publicly, since it might reveal the identity of its source and because it was unverified. Comer threatened to hold FBI Director Christopher A. Wray in contempt — again heightening the idea that the administration was trying to cover something up.

The public eventually learned the identity of the source when he was charged with inventing the bribery claim.

The vote to hold Garland in contempt (which passed on party lines Wednesday) followed a similar pattern. Garland declined to release the audio recording, citing executive privilege. So Jordan introduced a contempt resolution for Garland’s having failed to comply with a subpoena from his committee.

This is no longer a novel act. Attorney General Eric Holder was held in contempt by the Republican-led House in 2012 for not releasing material that had been requested. Attorney General William P. Barr was held in contempt by the House Democratic majority in 2019 for the same reason. Earlier this year, House Republicans upped the ante, impeaching Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas. The Senate basically ignored the move.

It is interesting to consider the efforts of the current majority in the context of Donald Trump’s push for reelection to the White House. In recent weeks, there’s been a lot of discussion about whether Trump would use the power of the presidency against his political opponents. House Republicans are demonstrating what that might look like, with allegations of impropriety and calls for punishment running well ahead of the evidence.

In fact, the conference keeps using its inability to uncover damning evidence as damning evidence of corruption. As House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) neared his decision to launch an impeachment probe, this was the argument he made: that evidence probably existed to prove Biden’s culpability but that the probe was needed to get that evidence. Constant pushing until they reach a limit — and then the limit is offered as proof of obstruction, used to level sanctions against Democrats.

Appearing on Fox Business after the Garland contempt vote, Comer was asked whether his ability to conduct oversight was broken.

“It’s been broken in a million pieces,” he moaned. “I mean, they will not turn over anything.”

Then he talked about how much the administration had turned over, but how it wasn’t what he wanted.

Read Entire Article